How To Choose The Best Email Marketing Provider For Your Small Business

  • email marketing service provider
Posted in: blog, Email Marketing Started by

Share and increase the ripple effect.Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInShare on Google+Pin on Pinterest

 

By now you know that email marketing is one of the single most effective ways to convert first-time web visitors into avid, lifetime customers.

You know that your business can’t get away without a stellar email marketing strategy—and you’re ready to start delivering quality content to your followers and subscribers.

But now that it’s time to get started with an email marketing strategy, here comes the tricky part:

How do you choose the best email service provider for your specific business’s needs and goals?

First off, know that there is no right or wrong answer to this question. Every entrepreneur has a different preference for their email marketing provider. A lot of it depends on what stage of your business you are at, what products or services you are offering and what ultimate business goals you have.

As with most elements of being a successful entrepreneur, the most important element is to get started—don’t get so hung up on choosing an email marketing provider that it keeps you from making progress with your email marketing strategy.

Why You Absolutely Must Have An Email Marketing Provider

That said, you absolutely must choose one of the various email marketing providers out there to support you in your email marketing strategy.

Sending bulk emails from your personal email address is frowned upon, and it could even get your account flagged as spam. Plus, as Bourne Creative so perfectly says it, not using a professional email marketing service provider sends a message to consumers that you don’t take your business seriously, or you’re too cheap to invest in its success.

Email marketing service providers also offer great additional tools, resources and analytics that allow you to get the most out of your email strategy.

Generally speaking, all email marketing service providers will allow you to:

  • Gather emails or opt-ins from your website
  • Store emails in a secure database
  • Segment emails into different lists
  • Analyze email open rates and click-throughs
  • Track unsubscribes

And that’s just the start! Each email marketing provider offers slightly different services at different rates, so it is important to explore all of your options.

While this is by no means a completely comprehensive list, here are a few of the more popular options:

email marketing provider

MailChimp

Many entrepreneurs and small businesses begin with MailChimp because they offer a free plan if you have less than 2,000 subscribers. However, it’s not easy or fun to switch from MailChimp to other email providers later on, so it’s important to look at what MailChimp offers in their paid packages and see if that will be right for your business when you max out on 2,000 subscribers—which I know you will.

Also note that MailChimp doesn’t offer an autoresponder in their free package. So while MailChimp might be a good option if all you want to do is send out nice looking newsletters, that’s about all you can do. You won’t be able to automatically send out an irresistible opt-in gift to those who sign-up for your list. And since I ALWAYS recommend having a juicy reason for people to sign up for your email list, I typically don’t suggest this option.

MailChimp’s paid packages do include an autoresponder, and starting as low as $10 a month, this is definitely one of the less expensive options. MailChimp also has nice designs and templates that are easy to customize for your brand.

One final note about MailChimp: some small businesses have noted that their accounts were blocked (with no prior warning) for incorporating affiliate links. This can be a huge deal breaker; if you’re blocked from your email list and can’t get access to it to funnel sales back into your business, then you’re loosing serious potential profit.

Aweber

Aweber is the email marketing service provider I use, and while it’s not perfect, it currently suits my needs. There is a one-month free trial so you can see if their services are right for you. Pricing then begins at $19 a month and increases depending on how many subscribers you have.

The area where Aweber really shines is in it’s fantastic autoresponder. Aweber dubs itself “the original autoresponder provider”, and as such, they have great automation options that allow you to send exactly what you want, when you want, to your particular emails lists.

In comparison to MailChimp, I find that Aweber has more advanced list segmentation, which allows me to send out super individualized emails. There is also no competition between customer service—Aweber has consistent and reliable support.

In terms of design, Aweber offers over 700 free templates to choose from. You can also design your own template, which makes it easy to match your emails to your business’s brand.

Infusionsoft

Infusionsoft is much more than an email marketing provider. It also functions as an e-commerce platform, a sales manager, a customer relationship manager—and that’s really just the start.

Monthly prices start at $199 for their most basic package. You can also spend an extra $1500 for onboarding support so you don’t have to spend quite as much time watching YouTube videos and wondering how to get the most out of the package.

Infusionsoft is one of the priciest platforms on this list, but that’s because it comes with all the bells and whistles your business could possibly want. If you are going to use all of the features that it includes, then Infusionsoft might be worth it. However, for most of you, it will probably be too much, and you’ll end up paying for tons of services that you aren’t using. There’s also a huge learning curve to getting the most out of InfusionSoft, so if you are going to invest here, make sure you have the time to get what you want out of it.

Ontraport

Ontraport is a popular alternative to Infusionsoft, and it tends to be the one that I recommend. Again, you’re getting much more than just an email marketing service provider when you sign up to Ontraport.

If you are an e-commerce business, then Ontraport is definitely worth considering. You’ll have some fantastic integrations that include Quick Books, PayPal, and 1 Shopping Cart—making it easier to manage all aspects of your business in one place. It’s also a great option for information-based products, or if you need more advanced technology to integrate and systemize your business.

Ontraport’s basic plan starts at $297 a month for up to 25,000 subscribers; this plan includes two hours of free training.

My Emma

My Emma is an increasingly popular email marketing platform, and those I know who use it, absolutely love it. My Emma boasts fantastic customer service, cool templates, and is a particularly great option for e-commerce businesses and non-profits.

There is a $250 start-up cost, but this one-time fee includes a custom template branded for your individual business. After that, monthly cost depends on your number of email subscribers. Packages start at $45 a month for up to 2,500 subscribers. For the amount of personalization and reports tracking you get with My Emma, the value is really phenomenal.

MadMimi

While not as well known as some of the other contenders on this list, MadMimi is a beautiful email marketing provider that does just about everything you need it to—at a very competitive price. Excellent customer service and the fact that it’s relatively easy to use make this a great option if you want something clean and professional. And while you won’t have some of the more advanced options like A/B testing, sometimes simplicity is exactly what you want. I don’t have personal experience using MadMimi, but you can read a full review here.

 

While it is possible to transfer emails from one service provider to another, it can be a serious pain. When choosing which email marketing provider is right for you and your business, think not only about where your business is at now, but where you WANT and EXPECT it to be.

For most entrepreneurs, I recommend starting with one of the more basic options, and as you continue to grow your business and start seeing a significant ROI from your list, then you can consider the pros and cons of moving to a more comprehensive online marketing platform such as Ontraport or Infusionsoft.

This guide is only meant to serve as an introduction to the different email marketing services available. As I noted in the introduction, there is no right or wrong email marketing service provider. Take the time to do your homework, research your options and align your future business goals with the individual features of each provider. And then, get started with a stellar email marketing strategy!

Which email marketing provider do you use? Any personal experience with the ones listed above?

 

Share and increase the ripple effect.Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInShare on Google+Pin on Pinterest

2 Comments

  1. Jill Sessa Reply

    The ability to easily integrate sign-up forms with your website has to be taken into consideration as well. I’m curious to hear if that is becoming easier for MyEmma and MadMimi. They now have Gravity Forms add-ons for both, so that’s a great way to accomplish it.

    Mailchimp has really upped their game in the last 12-18 months. Using Groups and automation based on actions- whether through e-commerce solutions, Google tracking or just plain old switching from one group to another, much more can be achieved. I marvel at the $10 plan for smaller clients. Add in something like Zapier and you really can cover a lot of the ground that the bigger names do.

    Another great round-up post, Lynan. Thanks!

  2. Samantha Whittaker Reply

    Thanks for this great post Lynan! I’ve been searching for a good resource to compare the different email marketing autoresponder services and this blog post really helped me to see the differences and make a choice that was right for me. Thank you so much!

Leave a Reply

Let's Connect

Your Name (required)

Your Email (required)

Subject

Your Message